Unraveling Luffy’s Lineage: Who Is His Mother?
Unraveling Luffy’s Lineage: Who Is His Mother?
I believe Luffy’s mother was an Amazon, more specifically the missing Amazonian Empress whose reign was between Shakky and Hancock. We know that Amazonian women leave the island and return pregnant, and that ONLY daughters are born.
According to the Greek Amazons legend, “The Amazons and Gargareans had for many generations met in secrecy once a year during two months in spring, in order to produce children.” These encounters would take place in accordance with ancient tribal customs and collective offers of sacrifices. All females were retained by the Amazons themselves, and males were returned to the Gargareans.
I believe Luffy’s mother (who I’ll call Lily) had a child with Dragon 19 years ago on the Kuja pirate ship. When they found he was a boy, they sent him to Dragon, who then gave the child to Garp to raise.
I believe Kuma chose to send Luffy to Amazon Lily since his mother was the former Empress. However, little did he know that Empress Lily had died due to love sickness, as she longed to be with her son but was unable to.
Luffy’s Mother Lineage Theory
- Luffy’s Mother theory suggests that Luffy’s lineage might be more complex than initially thought. The theory posits that Garp had a daughter, not a son, named Monkey D. Lucy. It argues that Dragon married Lucy and they had Luffy, whom Garp raised to protect from the government.
- The reasoning includes Garp’s unusual obsession with Luffy and Ace becoming marines, indicating a desire to shield them from the same fate that befell Luffy’s mother, whom he lost due to ‘justice.’
- Another point made in the theory is the significance of chapter 556, where Garp shows emotional turmoil about his family’s past. It is suggested that this chapter foreshadows Luffy’s mother’s tragic fate, possibly due to government injustice.
- Garp’s actions and emotions suggest he wants to protect his grandsons from becoming criminals like their mother, indicating a deep family trauma related to justice and loss.
- The name ‘Lucy,’ associated with Luffy’s gladiator identity as ‘Lucy, 0556,’ is also cited as a crucial foreshadow. This detail hints that Oda intended to link Luffy’s identity back to his mother, suggesting that Luffy embodies her dreams and ideals, which is why the theory claims he is her last hope to be saved.
Celestial Dragon Lineage Theory
- A popular theory regarding Luffy’s mother lineage suggests that she was a Celestial Dragon, a member of the World Government’s elite class. This could explain the strong connection between Luffy’s father, Monkey D. Dragon, a revolutionary, and the oppressive nature of the Celestial Dragons, potentially creating a powerful narrative of rebellion against his own family lineage.
- Contrasting Backgrounds: This theory creates a stark contrast between Luffy’s father, a revolutionary fighting against the World Government, and his mother, potentially being a high-ranking member of the very system his father opposes.
- Hidden Identity: Luffy’s mother’s identity could be deliberately hidden, explaining why her background is unknown in the story.
- Potential for Conflict: This could add another layer of complexity to Luffy’s journey, potentially leading to internal struggles if he were to discover his mother’s true lineage.
Important to :
- No Confirmed Information: As of now, Oda has not officially revealed any details about Luffy’s mother, leaving the specifics of her lineage open to speculation.
- Thematic Relevance: Regardless of the specific details, the theory of Luffy’s mother being a Celestial Dragon could add significant depth to the story, exploring themes of rebellion and the complexities of family lineage.
Theories Surrounding Luffy’s Unknown Mother
Luffy’s mother has been a subject of various theories within the One Piece community. Here are some of the most discussed theories surrounding her identity:
- Croco-Mom Theory: One of the prominent theories suggests that Luffy’s mother may actually be the ex-Warlord, Crocodile. This theory is based on dialogues and interactions between Crocodile and other characters, particularly Ivankov, who teases Crocodile about secrets from his past.
- Behavior at Marineford: A significant point in favor of this theory is Crocodile’s unusual behavior following the revelation of Luffy’s parentage at Marineford. His intervention during Ace’s execution and his protection of Luffy and Jinbe appear to suggest a deeper connection to Luffy, potentially indicating a maternal bond.
- Contradictory Actions: However, evidence against the Croco-Mom theory includes Crocodile’s attempts to kill Luffy during their encounters in Alabasta. This contradicts the idea of a maternal relationship, raising the question of why he would seek to harm his own son if he were aware of their connection. Some argue that Crocodile might not have recognized Luffy due to secrecy surrounding Luffy’s family’s identity.
- Trans Man Theory: Another variation of the theory posits that Luffy’s mom is actually Crocodile, based on the idea that Crocodile is a trans man. While this theory has its fans, it is considered shaky and could be contradicted by the potential appearance of Luffy and his mother in Chapter #1057.
- Obscured Face Evidence: A key point ing the idea of Crocodile as Luffy’s mother is the character’s obscured face during Gol D. Roger’s execution. Although there are hints from Eiichiro Oda that the theory, concrete information regarding Luffy’s mother remains elusive.
- Devil Fruit Theory: Another humorous theory suggests that Crocodile became Luffy’s mother due to a Devil Fruit power. An earlier theory claimed Crocodile was female before Ivankov altered her appearance. However, critics argue that if Crocodile were actually Luffy’s mother, he would have been aware of it.
- Other Theories: Additionally, some fans speculate that Luffy’s mother was a Tenryūbito who was punished for being with a commoner and a member of the D tribe. There is also a theory that suggests Luffy’s mother was an Amazon, specifically the missing Amazonian Empress who reigned between Shakky and Hancock.
Luffy’s Mom: Is She Alive or Just a Mystery?
Luffy’s Mother: Is She Alive or Just a Mystery?
Discussions surrounding Luffy’s mother frequently point towards Makino as a likely candidate. However, the theory that Crocodile, who is speculated to be a woman, could be Luffy’s mother has been circulating since the Impel Down arc. This theory continues to spark debate. Some argue that Crocodile represents Sand, while Imu symbolizes Earth, establishing a contrast between them.
Moreover, it has been noted that ‘Haha’ means mother in Japanese, which adds another layer to the mystery surrounding Luffy’s lineage. Some believe that Roger’s laughter during his execution was simultaneously a pun on ‘two mothers.’ Yet, there are claims suggesting that the references to Imu in Japanese indicate that he is male, since ‘Umi’ translates to sea, forming a clear anagram.
While some fans entertain the idea of Crocodile being Luffy’s mom, many dismiss it as implausible. Despite hints from Oda regarding female characters, such as “Crocomomsisters,” the truth about Luffy’s mother remains elusive. The only maternal figure Luffy has seen thus far is Dadan, considered a foster mom.
While ers of the Crocodile theory point to her obscured face during Gol D. Roger’s execution, others stress the shaky ground of this theory. It could be contradicted by the anticipated appearance of Luffy’s mother in chapter #1057. Currently, no concrete details about her character have been disclosed.
Interestingly, Eiichiro Oda may have hinted that Luffy’s mother could be the former Empress of Amazon Lily, known as Toritoma, as revealed in the SBS of One Piece Volume #109. In summary, it is posited that Luffy’s mother is a Tenryūbito who faced dire consequences for her relationship with a commoner from the D tribe.
Curly Dadan: Luffy’s Foster Mother Dynamics
Curly Dadan’s Role as Luffy’s Foster Mother
Curly Dadan is a friend of Monkey D. Garp and the foster mother of Portgas D. Ace and Monkey D. Luffy. Garp entrusted her to take care of Ace shortly after the boy’s birth. Later, Garp also left Luffy in Dadan’s care. After Sabo moved in, she also looked after him. Furthermore, Dadan lives on Mt. Colubo near Foosha Village and is the mountain bandit boss of the Dadan Family, a wanted criminal.
Dadan’s methods of discipline for both Luffy and Ace were somewhat questionable. These included providing them with limited food, making them clean the house, and hunting for them. However, judging from Luffy and Ace’s regard for her whenever she was mentioned, she may have been a better person than anyone may have thought. Additionally, she has shown bravery, as seen when she and her bandit family came to rescue Ace and Luffy from Bluejam.
Despite her tough exterior and claims of hating brats, Dadan appears to really care for Luffy and Ace as if they were her own children. However, she seems too embarrassed to it it. For instance, when Luffy and his crew returned two years after the Summit War of Marineford, Dadan was shown making photo albums of Luffy. After Luffy defeated Doflamingo, Dadan and the rest of the family celebrated Luffy’s accomplishments and bounty increase.
Dadan had issues with Sabo when they first met, but she eventually accepted him staying at her house with Ace and Luffy. When Dogra informed her of Sabo’s death, Dadan was surprised, just like Ace and Luffy. She later learned that he was not actually dead after the timeskip.
Curly Dadan embodies the stereotypical image of a criminal; however, she is a bit timid when it comes to Garp extorting her. Notably, she does not have much patience. Dadan became tired and sick of parenting Ace due to his antics, and when she was left with Luffy, she grew even angrier. Despite this, the other mountain bandits respect her greatly and follow her commands during combat.
Moreover, Dadan cried happily when Luffy confessed that he likes her and the family, despite his hatred of mountain bandits, before setting off on his journey to become a pirate.
Throughout her evolving relationship with Luffy and Ace, Dadan shows that true motherhood does not come from genetics but from the love, protection, and influence she provides. Although she may initially struggle to accept them into her bandit family, she gradually grows to care for them.
In contrast to Luffy’s birth mother, Dadan holds a crucial position in his life. She embodies the true meaning of motherhood that transcends mere familial ties. Some irers recognize Curly Dadan as Luffy’s guiding figure and adoptive mother, given her significant role in shaping his character.
The Connection Between Luffy and Monkey D. Dragon
Connection Between Monkey D. Dragon and Monkey D. Luffy
Monkey D. Dragon is the father of Monkey D. Luffy and the son of Monkey D. Garp. He was born in the Goa Kingdom, just like Luffy and Garp. However, Dragon was never a part of Luffy’s life, giving custody of him to Garp. Consequently, Luffy never knew or cared who his father was, only discovering it was Dragon two years ago when Garp revealed this at Water 7.
Despite this distance, Dragon does care for his son. He has occasionally watched over Luffy from afar, an event noted by Bartholomew Kuma. For instance, Dragon went to Loguetown to see Luffy leave for the Grand Line. He reflected at Baltigo that he hoped for Luffy’s pirating career to influence the world’s changes. To this, he saved Luffy from being captured by Smoker in Loguetown and anticipates reuniting with him in the future.
Moreover, Dragon has high expectations for Luffy, believing he will become a great man. Unlike Garp, who disapproves of Luffy’s choice to become a pirate, Dragon s Luffy’s freedom to live as he wishes.
During the Bartholomew Kuma flashbacks, it is confirmed that Dragon knows Luffy is his son. He indicates that stepping away from Luffy’s life is best to keep their connection obscure. This situation has sparked discussions among fans about Dragon’s motivations for having a son and his feelings towards Luffy.
Hints suggest that Dragon indeed cares for Luffy. He made a detour to visit the East Blue, explicitly saving Luffy from Smoker during their initial meeting, marking one of the few times Dragon played a significant role in the story’s plot.
Although Luffy discovered that Dragon, the most wanted man in the world, is his father, the two have not yet had a conversation. Their sole interaction remains Dragon’s rescue of Luffy from Smoker.
Additionally, it is shown in the One Piece manga that Dragon does care about Luffy. When Kuma inquired about Dragon’s relationship with Luffy in the East Blue, Dragon became defensive, revealing a deeper motivation: ‘Children are vulnerable to any parent.’ This line showcases Dragon’s paternal instincts as a father.
